write a review

Please note this page is for product reviews only, not customer service inquiries.

If you need assistance with your order please visit our help page at www.fragrancenet.com/help.

Tell us in detail what you liked or did not like about this product - What did it smell like to you? Was it long lasting? Would you recommend it to a friend? Tell us everything!
(maximum of 150 words)

Please provide a rating and review text
Your review must contain at least 4 words
A star rating is required

Customer Reviews

For Replica Under The Stars

by Maison Margiela

Amazing! Strong and masculine! I am female but like masculine smells! Heavy in the leather. Lasted long. I can still smell it after 5 hours. I mixed it with a more feminine perfume (layered it) and that worked well also. But the longevity was Under the Stars. It is a better one and surprised many do not like this. Perhaps because it is heavy and masculine? Not unusual smell persay. Not unique. But great! Some reviews state they smelled patchouly, but I do not smell it. I like patchouly a lot so a little disappointed on that one. It was a blind guy for me and I’m definitely keeping it and adding it to my collection. Awesome!!

Written by Lolo on December 16, 2025

Was this review helpful?

Yes / No

Be the first to provide feedback on this review.

I was put off when i got this, way strong, didn't like the scent. Month went past, a little colder out, put some on, i fell in love, so did others.

Written by Chris on August 27, 2025

Was this review helpful?

Yes / No

Be the first to provide feedback on this review.

This perfume is so strong and long lasting. It smells of leather and oud and smoke. Very masculine leaning and more for the dark feminine. There is nothing light and fresh about this fragrance. It is sexy and has a very powerful sillage. One of my absolute favorites.

Written by Marty on July 22, 2025

Was this review helpful?

Yes / No

Be the first to provide feedback on this review.